Editors Pick

COMMENTARY: Forget the Adversity Score, Just Dump the SAT | BlackPressUSA


By Julianne Malveaux, NNPA Newswire Contributor

The College Board, the organization that develops and administers the SAT test, has developed a new “adversity score” to augment the widely used college admissions examination. The fact that the College Board has had to create an “adversity score” is reason enough to discard the badly flawed SAT test, a test that many consider racially biased, and that only measures the likelihood of first-year college success. In other words, it measures the accumulated advantages that some students have over others because of the quality of their high schools, their family wealth, and other factors. The “adversity score” seeks to measure the disadvantages that some students experience. Interestingly, the “adversity score” does not measure race, although racial discrimination is alive and well in our nation.

Indeed, the development of an adversity score that does not account for race is a capitulation to the anti-affirmative action forces, some directed by this administration’s Justice Department that have brought lawsuits against Harvard and other universities because of “anti-Asian” bias. It is also a bow to the argument that a white student from a poor family is more disadvantaged than a black child whose family is upper-middle-class when there is plenty of evidence that this is not necessarily so. Structural racism is so woven into our national consciousness that a child of middle-class black folks is likely to do worse than their parents did. Our nation is in race denial, and this adversity score, which does not consider race, is part of the denial.

The pilot testing of the adversity score seems to indicate that using it may create more diverse admissions, but there are precious few details about the score (and it won’t even be shared with students and their parents). But the very existence of an adversity score raises questions about the efficacy of the SAT. This is perhaps why.

This is an interesting time for the adversity score to be rolled out. Robert Schaffer, Public Education Director of Fair Test (the National Center for Fair and Open Testing) says the adversity scores are a way for the College Board to defend itself against its critics. He said, “Schools do not need the SAT or ACT – with or without ‘adversity scores’ – to make high-quality, admissions decisions that promote equity and excellence.” In fact, more than 1000 colleges and universities, including half for the top 100 liberal arts colleges, do not use the SAT to evaluate applicants.

What should colleges use, instead, to evaluate students? How about high school grades? Some will argue that the quality of high schools varies. Well, that ought to be an impetus for improving the quality of some high schools, especially those in inner cities. How about class rank? The University of Texas uses class rank to admit some students, which ensures a diverse class given the segregation that remains in our nation’s high schools. The adversity score will purportedly reflect differences in high school quality.

Eliminating the use of the SAT would do much the same, allowing college admissions counselors to make better decisions. The College Board says it is a nonprofit organization, but let’s follow the money. It makes so much money that its President, David Coleman, earns more than a million dollars a year, more than the President of Harvard University. The organization is making megabucks on the backs of our students, and it is reinforcing biases along the way. Some see the adversity score as a step in the right direction toward modifying the SAT. I see it as a defensive move to shore up a flawed test and an even more flawed organization.

This fall, more than 150 colleges will use the adversity-enhanced SAT in their admissions process. Based on those results, more colleges will use the score to measure adversity. I know lots of folks who consider the development of an adversity score good news. It would be much better news if colleges and universities simply decided to stop using the SAT. It measures privilege, not knowledge, and it is demonstrably biased. Fixing a corrupt system instead of changing it only serves to reinforce the status quo.

Julianne Malveaux is an author and economist. Her latest project MALVEAUX! On UDCTV is available on youtube.com. For booking, wholesale inquiries or for more info visit www.juliannemalveaux.com.




Source link

health news headlines provided courtesy of Medical News Today.

Advertisement

Advertisement Small

Follow Me

Collaboratively harness market-driven processes whereas resource-leveling internal or "organic" sources. Competently formulate.

View More Job Search Results

Calendar

August 2019
M T W T F S S
« Jul    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

Pages

Recent Comments

    RSS Meks Blog

    • Useful rank tracking plugin and tools recommendation to improve your WordPress website SEO August 15, 2019
      Are you looking for a reliable rank tracking plugin to track your rankings on search engines and improve SEO strategy? Here is our top recommendation! The post Useful rank tracking plugin and tools recommendation to improve your WordPress website SEO appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • 6 reasons why you should never use WordPress nulled themes August 7, 2019
      What are WordPress nulled themes and should you use them, are they really that bad as people say or it’s just to scare you away from using the good stuff for free? In this article, we’re explaining in details why you should never ever use these kinds of themes. The post 6 reasons why you […]
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • Top 6 WordPress Portfolio plugins (hand-picked by designers!) July 31, 2019
      Wondering what type of WordPress Portfolio plugins to use to showcase your work? Read our recommendation and choose between these top eight I present to you today. The post Top 6 WordPress Portfolio plugins (hand-picked by designers!) appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • Definitive guide to adding Facebook Pixel in WordPress July 24, 2019
      Having problems setting up Facebook Pixel in WordPress? If you want to improve your Facebook ads conversion, use this guide and learn how to properly ad Facebook Pixel in any WordPress site or blog. The post Definitive guide to adding Facebook Pixel in WordPress appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • How to easily create WordPress dropdown menu (without coding) July 17, 2019
      Interested to create WordPress dropdown menu all by yourself and don’t know how? Just follow our guide and learn in no time! The post How to easily create WordPress dropdown menu (without coding) appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • 12 must join Facebook groups for photographers July 11, 2019
      Whether it’s for constructive feedback or new learnings, these Facebook groups for photographers are a great networking place to be in! The post 12 must join Facebook groups for photographers appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • Easy guide on how to make your WordPress site private July 4, 2019
      Wondering how to make your WordPress site private knowing there is no built-in option to it? Read our guide and learn all about it! The post Easy guide on how to make your WordPress site private appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • 10+ email list building ideas and tools (to easily grow your customer base) June 27, 2019
      What are some of the most efficient email list building ideas and tools to grow your audience in 2019 and beyond? Here’s our recommendation! The post 10+ email list building ideas and tools (to easily grow your customer base) appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • The future of WordPress and Gutenberg Editor – Matt’s talk at WordCamp Europe 2019 June 22, 2019
      What seems to be the future of WordPress and Gutenberg Editor? These are the topics Matt covered in his summer state of WordPress at WCEU in Berlin and all the great things coming ahead. The post The future of WordPress and Gutenberg Editor – Matt’s talk at WordCamp Europe 2019 appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • How to easily add Google Fonts to your WordPress website June 19, 2019
      Do you want to add Google fonts to your WordPress website? Here’s how you can freshen up your web place and make it faster, trendy and more appealing. The post How to easily add Google Fonts to your WordPress website appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic

    Text

    Distinctively utilize long-term high-impact total linkage whereas high-payoff experiences. Appropriately communicate 24/365.

    Archives