Business

Investing green is all the rage, but benchmarks still hazy

SYDNEY (Reuters) – Global money managers and companies are rushing to meet a deadline to report on their carbon footprint, but the lack of a standard metric raises concerns their efforts could just be a box-ticking exercise in the transition from brown to green.

FILE PHOTO: Power-generating windmill turbines are pictured during sunset at a wind park in Campeneac, France, September 3, 2019. REUTERS/Gonzalo Fuentes

From 2020, firms with some $118 trillion of funds under management – among 800 signatories to a United Nations pact – will make climate-risk related disclosures as an early step towards making the world a better place by 2030.

The problem with assessing carbon footprints is that there are no universal criteria for benchmarking environmental, social and governance (ESG) – the key factors in measuring the sustainability and ethical impact of an investment.

“The way you quantify climate impact and consider transition risks could differ from company to company,” said Stephane Andre, a Sydney-based portfolio manager at Alphinity Investments which has A$8.2 billion ($5.65 billion) in assets under management.

“There is no prescriptive way to look at it,” he added. “What it means is in the short term there might be limited value in it.”

That hasn’t stopped stakeholders such as Andre from piling pressure on companies to tackle the 17 United Nations ‘sustainable development goals’ such as zero hunger, gender equality and clean energy.

Mining titan BHP Billiton (BHP.AX) surprised markets this year when it announced plans to cut carbon emissions not just at its own facilities but for its customers as well. It exited some coal projects, on the heels of rival Rio Tinto (RIO.L).

Large banks have begun disclosing their carbon exposures while setting targets for clean lending, while insurers including Chubb (CB.BN) (CB.N) and Suncorp (SUN.AX), have moved away from coverage for new coal projects.

Top U.S. retailer Walmart (WMT.N) said this month it would stop selling ammunition for handguns in all its stores across the country and Australia’s Woolworths (WOW.AX) became the first supermarket chain in the world to issue a certified climate bond this year.

Despite a blitz of such corporate announcements, fund managers are constantly trying to differentiate between genuine ESG and spin by looking for deeper disclosures from the companies they screen, in areas such as gender pay gap and relationship with employees and suppliers.

But not all companies publish data on ESG impact yet, and analyzing data from those that do is also challenging. “Data isn’t always readily available, and not all investors have access to advanced analytical tools or various ESG data sets,” said Jessica Huang, head of Americas and APAC platform for Blackrock Sustainable Investing. “Investors often rely too much on historical data, which may not provide an accurate prediction of future trends.”

ESG SCORE

Some investment managers use so-called ESG ratings provided by firms such as Fitch Ratings.

One MSCI study found that companies with higher average ESG ratings had lower risks, greater profitability and higher dividend yields. Yet, those ESG scores are based on the levels of disclosure by a company, not an actual assessment of practices.

Worryingly, a comparison of FTSE and MSCI ESG scores has hardly any correlation, said Mike Lubrano, managing director for corporate governance & sustainability at Cartica Management.

Variations in the components and weightings of the underlying metrics used by different index providers also generate widely divergent scores, he noted.

Despite the challenges of measuring ESG performance, investments in the stream are rising. Investors believe that if companies do well on ESG metrics, such focus will make their businesses more sustainable in the long term.

Indeed, an analysis of the top 500 companies in Asia, based on ESG metrics, shows their average returns outperformed the broader MSCI Asia Pacific index .MIAPJ0000PUS each time in the last 10 years.

(GRAPHIC: Asian ESG leaders’ price performance – tmsnrt.rs/2Adko9m)

Data from Lipper showed assets under management of ethical, water and alternative energy funds in Asia climbed 16% to $28.5 billion in the first half of 2019 from a year ago.

In debt markets, climate bond issuances surpassed $150 billion this year though still a far cry from the $1 trillion goal for 2020, according to Climate Bonds Initiative.

The increased momentum has meant that banks are engaging more actively with their corporate clients while shareholders are rallying behind green groups demanding companies cut emissions, lift governance and improve social responsibilities.

So called responsible investors also shun industries that negatively affect society, including companies that produce or invest in alcohol, tobacco, gambling and guns.

Such activism prompted Australian supermarket giant Woolworths (WOW.AX) to finally agree, after years of engagement with investors, to offload its profitable pub and liquor business in July.

“Poker machines are horrible things but they are very profitable,” said Bruce Smith, another portfolio manager at Alphinity. “Once they get rid of that business, Woolworths will become a possible investment for us.”

Woolworths did not specifically comment on its decision, saying only that the move would help it simplify its structure and focus on the retail business.

Additional reporting by Gaurav Dogra in BENGALURU; Editing by Vidya Ranganathan and Jacqueline Wong


Source link

health news headlines provided courtesy of Medical News Today.

Advertisement

Advertisement Small

Follow Me

Collaboratively harness market-driven processes whereas resource-leveling internal or "organic" sources. Competently formulate.

View More Job Search Results

Calendar

May 2020
M T W T F S S
« Apr    
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Pages

Recent Comments

    RSS Meks Blog

    • How to change the WordPress username? An easy step-by-step guide May 14, 2020
      Wondering how can you change WordPress username once you set up your blog or site? Read all about it in our helpful guide! The post How to change the WordPress username? An easy step-by-step guide appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • What’s the best WordPress comment plugin to use? April 13, 2020
      Wondering whether to use WordPress comment plugin or go with the native option? Here are our thoughts and recommendation on which one to choose. The post What’s the best WordPress comment plugin to use? appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • Top 12 WordPress Newsletter plugin recommendations March 17, 2020
      What better way to gain more subscribers and grow your email list than with a little help of a top WordPress newsletter plugin, right? Only, with so many of them on the market – which one to choose? The post Top 12 WordPress Newsletter plugin recommendations appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • Top 3 proven methods to monetize your WordPress site or blog December 17, 2019
      Eager to learn how to monetize your WordPress site or blog in an easy way? Read our guide and learn all about it! The post Top 3 proven methods to monetize your WordPress site or blog appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • Top 8 WordPress audio player plugins to enhance your podcast or music November 15, 2019
      What are the top WordPress audio player plugins to choose from for your next music or podcast project? Take your pick from our suggestions! The post Top 8 WordPress audio player plugins to enhance your podcast or music appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • How to add Instagram photo feed to your WordPress site (in 5 minutes!) October 1, 2019
      How (and why) to add Instagram to WordPress and see more benefits from that match? We give you all the details and tools to do it successfully yourself! The post How to add Instagram photo feed to your WordPress site (in 5 minutes!) appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • 15 best headline & blog title generator tools to easily boost your SEO September 12, 2019
      Ready to increase traffic to your website today? Use these headline generator tools and improve your click-through-rates! The post 15 best headline & blog title generator tools to easily boost your SEO appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • How to create a Facebook Page for your blog (plus PRO tips) September 4, 2019
      Wondering how to create a Facebook Page for your blog knowing that you really do need one? Follow our in depth guide and learn how to create and manage attractive and successful Facebook Page! The post How to create a Facebook Page for your blog (plus PRO tips) appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • Beginners guide on how to redirect a page in WordPress August 29, 2019
      Whether you’re trying to redirect a page in WordPress or just want to discover and understand why it’s important, use this guide to help you get ahead of it and learn all there is to it. The post Beginners guide on how to redirect a page in WordPress appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • The best Facebook Groups for SEO to improve your knowledge and rankings August 21, 2019
      Are you tired of searching for the best Facebook groups for SEO to improve your knowledge and learn about the tricks from the trade? The post The best Facebook Groups for SEO to improve your knowledge and rankings appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic

    Text

    Distinctively utilize long-term high-impact total linkage whereas high-payoff experiences. Appropriately communicate 24/365.

    Archives