Politics

Love you have to coerce is not love at all | Leonard Pitts Jr. | Columns

There’s an old song that always comes to mind at times like this.

“I’m Gonna Make You Love Me” — a 1968 hit for the Temptations and the Supremes — is a litany of lavish promises: “Every minute, every hour, I’m gonna shower you with love and affection — look out, it’s coming in your direction. I’m gonna make you love me.”

As boy meets girl sentiment, it is harmless and sweet. But as government policy, it is something else, entirely. What does it mean, after all, when the state says, “I’m gonna make you love me”?

For an 11-year-old black boy in Lakeland, Florida, it meant being arrested.

It happened earlier this month — the story came to widespread attention only last week — after the child, whose name has not been released, refused to join his class in expressing love of country. Which is to say, he defied a substitute teacher’s order to stand and say the Pledge of Allegiance. The Pledge, he said, represents racism.

There followed a standoff with the sub who probably didn’t know and maybe didn’t care that the boy has been refusing to take the pledge all year. As reported by Bay News 9, a TV station in St. Petersburg, which obtained the teacher’s written statement, she asked why he didn’t go somewhere else to live if America is so bad.

She said the boy responded, “They brought me here.”

The teacher said she told him, “Well, you can always go back, because I came here from Cuba and the day I feel I’m not welcome here anymore I would find another place to live.” Thereby equating her decision to flee a totalitarian regime with the kidnapping at gunpoint of this child’s ancestors.

Compounding her cluelessness, the woman called administrators, who called police. They claim the boy was arrested because he became disruptive, refused to follow instructions and resisted arrest without violence. Which feels like a lame excuse for an indefensible overreaction, especially given that school policy — and a little thing called the First Amendment — give him the right to opt out of the Pledge. Small wonder a prosecutor has declined to prosecute.

And here, one might declaim about how readily schools criminalize ordinary disciplinary issues where children of color are concerned. One might also observe that doing so rather proves the boy’s point about the Pledge. But leave that for another time. Focus instead on the coercive thing the state sought to do: make this boy love — or say he loves — America.

As the ongoing argument over Colin Kaepernick and the recurring debate over flag burning suggest, many of us have an unfortunate taste for forced patriotism. It’s worth noting that in 1940, the Supreme Court upheld the expulsion of two young Jehovah’s Witnesses from a Pennsylvania school after they refused to recite the Pledge on religious grounds.

It’s also worth noting that just three years later — on Flag Day, no less, in the middle of World War II — the Court reversed itself. Writing for the majority, Justice Robert H. Jackson stated the obvious: “To believe that patriotism will not flourish if patriotic ceremonies are voluntary and spontaneous instead of a compulsory routine is to make an unflattering estimate of the appeal of our institutions to free minds.”

In other words, love you have to coerce is not love at all, something too many Americans still cannot get through their heads — including, apparently, a certain teacher from Cuba. As a pop song, “I’m Gonna Make You Love Me” was flirty and fun. But when a government says, “I’m gonna make you love me,” what it’s really saying is, “I’m gonna make you obey me.”

Isn’t that what people leave Cuba to escape?

========

(Leonard Pitts is a columnist for The Miami Herald, 1 Herald Plaza, Miami, Fla., 33132. Readers may contact him via e-mail at lpitts@miamiherald.com.)




Source link

health news headlines provided courtesy of Medical News Today.

Advertisement

Advertisement Small

Flickr

  • Paranoids
  • prolog
  • Just before rain
  • 86 Fahrenheit
  • Vivian
  • badinage
  • ceinturon
  • Zuzanas
  • Xandra

About Author

Follow Me

Collaboratively harness market-driven processes whereas resource-leveling internal or "organic" sources. Competently formulate.

ThemeForest

Collaboratively harness market-driven processes whereas resource-leveling internal or "organic" sources. Competently formulate.

  • Johannes - Multi-concept Personal Blog & Magazine WordPress theme
  • Opinion - Modern News & Magazine Style WordPress Theme
  • Trawell - WordPress travel theme
  • Pinhole - WordPress Gallery Theme for Photographers
  • Typology - Text Based Minimal WordPress Blog Theme
  • Gridlove - Creative Grid Style News & Magazine WordPress Theme
  • Vlog - Video Blog / Magazine WordPress Theme
  • Herald - News Portal & Magazine WordPress Theme
  • Sidewalk - Elegant Personal Blog WordPress Theme

View more

View More Job Search Results

Calendar

June 2019
M T W T F S S
« May    
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930

Pages

Recent Comments

    RSS Meks Blog

    • Using Google Trends for market research to leverage your content creation ideas June 12, 2019
      Did you know you can use Google Trends for market research and target your customer needs, tailor content strategy, in a much better way? The post Using Google Trends for market research to leverage your content creation ideas appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • How WordPress can help you to build and increase brand awareness June 6, 2019
      How can you build and improve brand awareness with WordPress and what steps are needed in that strategy? The post How WordPress can help you to build and increase brand awareness appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • Starting a photography blog: The secrets successful photo bloggers won’t tell you May 30, 2019
      Is starting a photography blog the next step for your personal branding and getting out there with your work? Sure is! And here’s how you can do it! The post Starting a photography blog: The secrets successful photo bloggers won’t tell you appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • 5+ best forum plugins for WordPress to build a loyal community in 2019 May 22, 2019
      Looking for the best forum plugin for WordPress to build a community and keep them engaged? Let us save you the time and choose among these 6 we recommend. The post 5+ best forum plugins for WordPress to build a loyal community in 2019 appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • Easily setup Facebook instant articles for your WordPress website (plus tips & tricks ) May 16, 2019
      In case you still haven’t set up Facebook Instant Articles for your WordPress blog or site, here’s why we recommend you to do it. The post Easily setup Facebook instant articles for your WordPress website (plus tips & tricks ) appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • 8 things people usually miss before starting a blog May 8, 2019
      Have you ever wondered what things need to be done before starting a blog or do you think it’s just writing and not much else? Boy, are you in for a surprise! The post 8 things people usually miss before starting a blog appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • WordPress RSS feed plugin – 7 recommendations 2019 edition May 1, 2019
      Wondering whether you need a WordPress RSS feed plugin or not? Let us show you what beautiful things you can make with it! The one thing people nowadays tend to say is that emails and RSS feeds are dead. A fact that couldn’t be more from the actual truth. Knowing that we live in a […]
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • How to make money as a travel blogger (10 tips you can start using today) April 23, 2019
      Have you ever wondered how to make money as a travel blogger, especially when you see how many are out there doing it? Here are at least ten ways you can, too! The post How to make money as a travel blogger (10 tips you can start using today) appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • 6+ video marketing tips to improve your vlogging [2019 edition] April 17, 2019
      Wondering what would be some of the best video marketing tips that can help you step up your vlogging game? We’ve got you covered! The post 6+ video marketing tips to improve your vlogging [2019 edition] appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic
    • 18 top Google Chrome extensions for WordPress April 10, 2019
      Looking for the most useful WordPress Chrome extensions to make your site more functional and engaging? Take a look at our list of top Chrome addons to use! The post 18 top Google Chrome extensions for WordPress appeared first on Meks.
      Ivana Cirkovic

    Text

    Distinctively utilize long-term high-impact total linkage whereas high-payoff experiences. Appropriately communicate 24/365.

    Archives